Orangeville Tavern Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Orangeville Tavern, a cozy gem nestled in Sharpsville, PA. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, it’s the perfect spot for casual dining and friendly gatherings. The menu features an impressive selection of a la carte dishes catered to all tastes. Indulge in the tantalizing loaded mac and cheese bowls, or keep it classic with the ribeye and grilled chicken salad. If you're craving something comforting, the homemade chili and vegetable soup are not to be missed.

Sandwich lovers will delight in options like the steak sandwich and fish sandwich, both crafted with care and bursting with flavor. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and reasonable prices, making it an excellent choice for a quick dinner or casual lunch. As Vicki Mead aptly describes, the Tavern exudes a “down home” feel that makes every visit feel special. Join us for a truly pleasant dining experience!

Soup & Chile

Small Home Made Vegetable Soup

US$1.75

Large Homemade Made Vegetable Soup

US$2.00

Small Homemade Chili

US$1.75

Large Homemade Chili

US$2.00

Ribeye

US$3.95

Steak Sandwich W/grilled Onions

US$1.95

Hamburger 1/4lb

US$2.35

Cheeseburger

US$2.65

Grilled Cheese

US$1.75

Meatball Splash W/fries

US$4.25

Meatball Sandwich

US$2.75

Fish Sandwich

US$3.00

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

US$3.95

Sandwiches

Pizza

Cheese

US$5.00

Extra Cheese

US$1.25

Pepperoni

US$1.00

Sausage

US$1.00

Mushroom

US$1.00

Hot Peppers

US$1.00

Grilled Chicken Salad W/roll

US$5.95

Chef Salad Small

US$4.50

Chef Salad Large

US$5.50

Cheese Plate W/pepperoni

US$2.75

A La Carte Dishes

Side Orders

Veggie Platter

US$4.95

Poppers

US$2.75

Onion Rings

US$1.50

Fried Mushrooms

US$1.50